Sarah Presler/Presley was born in 1731, to her father, Pieter (Peter Presley). Her mother is unknown but may have been Mary Smith.
Sarah married Jeffrey Johnson about 1745 in Prince William, Virginia. They had seven children in 19 years: James Boswell, Elizabeth, Lydia, Mary, Alexander, Presley, and Bailey.
Sarah Presler Presley lived in Accomack, Virginia, in 1780.
She died in 1785 in Virginia at the age of 54.